Methodology
How the research works.
The same method for every school. Every claim rests on evidence, and every piece of evidence links to its source. Where we could not find something, we say so.
Claim, evidence, source
Everything on a school page is built from three parts.
- The claim: one statement, in plain words, attributed to whoever made it. A school's own statement is labelled as the school's, and rests on the school's own source.
- The evidence: the exact words from a source, with where they appear (a page, a section, a table row). We keep the source's own language, such as “alleged”, “pending” or “denied”.
- The source: the document itself, with its publisher, its date, the date we read it, and an archived copy where one exists.
A source we have not opened is never cited. Translations are marked as ours. A claim never says more than its evidence, and a summary never says more than its claims.
The checks before anything is published
Before a claim reaches the page, automated checks confirm that:
- the quoted words are found in the source we saved;
- every number in the claim appears in its evidence;
- hedge words in the source, such as “reportedly”, survive in the claim;
- stronger words than the source uses are flagged;
- personal names are flagged for review.
Then the publisher reviews it. The database itself refuses to publish a claim without verified evidence.
Questions we ask of a school's figures
For a figure such as a placement rate, we ask what a careful applicant would ask:
- Of whom: which programme, which graduating year?
- Out of how many: all graduates, or only those who used the school's placement service?
- What counts: any offer, an accepted offer, a full-time role, within what period?
- Is the method published, and has it changed between years? Is the report audited?
- What did the school claim before? Do official or independent sources confirm or complicate it?
“Not stated by the source” is an acceptable answer, and often the most useful one.
Where we look
Every source is shown with its family, so you can see at a glance who is speaking.
- From the school
Its website, including archived versions, prospectuses, fee documents, placement reports, annual reports and press releases. What the school says is always shown as the school's.
- Official record
Regulators and government registers, accreditation bodies, courts, and public statistics. For example, the UK's Office for Students and HESA, Spain's register of universities and degrees, and India's UGC and NIRF.
- Independent
Reputable national and local news, investigative reporting, academic databases, and ranking publishers' own tables and methods.
- Calculated by Skone
A figure we worked out from published numbers, shown with the numbers and the method.
Forum and social media posts are opinion. We use them only as leads to official documents, never as evidence, and we never copy usernames or personal details from them.
The checklist every school goes through
Every school is researched against the same checklist, because uneven scrutiny reads as bias even when every fact is right. The topics:
- identity and status;
- accreditation and recognition;
- admissions;
- cost and value;
- academics and faculty;
- career outcomes;
- rankings;
- legal and regulatory;
- institution and governance;
- student experience.
For each topic, the checklist names the kinds of source to check in the school's country. Research stops only when each topic is either documented from the strongest sources available, or recorded as something we could not establish.
When we could not find it
Finding nothing is a result. When reliable evidence does not exist in public, the page says so under “What remains unclear”, and lists the sources we checked and when.
“We could not find” means exactly that: we looked in the places listed and did not find it. It does not mean the school is hiding something, and it does not mean the school's figure is wrong. It means you may want to ask the school.
High-risk items, and how schools respond
Lawsuits, investigations, regulator actions, allegations and controversies are high-risk items. Each one is reviewed and approved by the publisher on its own, and keeps the source's status words, such as “filed”, “pending” or “denied”. They are shown on the page, and never counted in the score.
Before a high-risk item is first published:
- We email the school's press or communications office from responses@skone.app, with the exact statement, its sources and a link to this page.
- The school has 7 days to respond, or 14 days when the item is complex, such as a court case with several parts.
- We record any response exactly as received and publish it beside the item, unless the school asks us not to.
A response is never a veto: it is shown beside the item and cannot change it. A public statement the school has already made is attached without asking. Other items are not sent to schools before publication, but a school can respond to any item at any time.
Corrections
If something is wrong, write to corrections@skone.app. We check it against the sources. If the record is wrong, we correct or withdraw the claim and say so in a public corrections log that cannot be edited or deleted.
When a school changes what it says, we do not overwrite the old claim. We record the new one, and the old one can stay on the page, marked as historical. How corrections work.
The score
The score asks one question: how far can an applicant trust what this school tells them, and how much of its effort goes into selling itself rather than teaching? It has four parts, each scored out of 100:
- Transparency
Does the school publish what an applicant needs?
- Claims check
Do the school's own claims hold up?
- Marketing restraint
How much of the school's effort goes into selling itself? A higher score means more restraint.
- Education investment
How much goes into teaching?
The overall score is the average of the four, shown only when at least three of them have enough evidence. A part is shown only when at least half of its questions are answered.
A missing answer is never zero. “The school does not publish this” is an answer, and it scores. “We have not checked this yet” is not an answer, and is left out. A school without enough evidence comes last in a sorted list, never with a low number.
It is provisional. The bands are first estimates (method scoring/0). They will be recalibrated once 20 schools have real data, and every change of method gets a new version. Only evidence the publisher has approved counts, and every number opens to the answers and claims behind it.
What it does not measure: teaching quality, prestige, graduates' salaries, ranking positions, what students say, or legal and regulatory matters. Those are either contested data or verdicts we do not issue.
Marketing is scored against what the school discloses, never for the act of advertising. No red or green, no stars.
Every question in the score
A. Transparency
- Is the full cost of the flagship programme published, with every mandatory fee and deposit, for a stated intake?
- Are employment outcomes for the flagship programme published, with the cohort, the period and the denominator or response rate?
- Do the outcomes follow a published reporting standard, or are they independently audited? Examples: the MBA CSEA standards, the UK Graduate Outcomes survey, Australia's QILT, or an audit.
- Is every accreditation or recognition the school claims confirmed by the accreditor or regulator?
- Does the school say plainly what each programme awards, and does the official record agree? An example is an official degree versus the school's own degree (título propio).
- Are audited financial statements, or a public tax filing, available?
B. Claims check
- Of the school's own published claims (attributed statements and metrics) that could be checked, what share do official or independent sources confirm? Worked out from the school's published claims, never assessed by hand.
- Are the ranking positions the school advertises confirmed by the ranking publisher's own published table?
C. Marketing restraint
- What share of total spending goes to advertising, marketing and recruitment, from audited accounts or tax filings?
- Does the school recruit through paid agents in India?
- How many active advertisements from the school reach India in the public ad libraries on the date checked?
D. Education investment
- What share of total spending goes to teaching and academic departments, from accounts or official statistics?
- Students per full-time-equivalent academic staff member, from official statistics or the school's audited figure.
- What share of teaching staff are employed full time?